OUR SUGAR COOKIE FLAVORS
Fresh Baked to Order
From traditional vanilla sugar cookie flavor to more adventurous flavors like Cheddar Jalepeño we have a flavor to suit every taste.
CARAMEL BY THE BAY - EXCLUSIVE FLAVOR
Premium Flavor Group
This is our EXCLUSIVE recipe combining sweet caramel with Old Bay (TM) seasoning to create a flavor that is inspired by our favorite boardwalk popcorn flavor. If you know, you know.
VANILLA SUGAR COOKIE
Standard Flavor Group
With the perfect balance of sweet and salty, soft bite with just a hint of crunch, these cookies pair perfectly with all our icing flavors.
CHOCOLATE BROWNIE SUGAR COOKIE
Standard Flavor Group
This cookie has a rich chocolate flavor and a soft bite. Pairs well with Vanilla icing for a decorated cookie and with Chocolate icing for a plain iced cookie.
LEMON DREAM SUGAR COOKIES
Special Flavor Group
There’s something so sweet about these tart little gems! For that extra punch of flavor, pair it with our Lemon frosting or tame it down with our Vanilla or Cream Cheese Frosting.
SALTED LIME REFRESHER COOKIE
Special Flavor Group
Another in-house favorite! These cookies have just the right amount of sweet and the right amount of tart. We love them with Vanilla Icing as well as the Lime Icing, but we’re pretty sure they’d be spectacular with the Cream Cheese Icing too!
CONFETTI CAKE SUGAR COOKIES
Special Flavor Group
Sprinkles always make things more festive! This twist on our Sugar Cookie adds a bit of fun to the cookie.
GINGERBREAD SUGAR COOKIES
Special Flavor Group
Evoking feelings of winter, Christmases by the tree, making cookies with family or even your great grandmother’s special recipe cookies, this recipe will fill you with warm feelings. A perfect companion icing is our Cream Cheese or I Can’t Believe It’s Not Butter Cream Icing.
COOKIES & CREAM SUGAR COOKIES
Special Flavor Group
With real crushed chocolate sandwich cookies inside, these cookies & cream sugar cookies are a tasty treat! Perfect with our Vanilla icing.
PUMPKIN SPICE SUGAR COOKIE
Special Flavor Group
At the first hint of fall, thoughts turn to hayrides, campfires, sweaters and Pumkin Spice. These Pumpkin Spice sugar cookies taste like Thanksgiving! Perfect with Vanilla, Cream Cheese or Buttercream Icing.
CARROT CAKE SUGAR COOKIE
Special Flavor Group
A new twist on an old classic. Think of it as Carrot Cake but as finger food! Absolutely delicious paired with our cream cheese frosting. Also yummy plain!
SWEET HONEY MUSTARD PRETZEL SUGAR COOKIE
Premium Flavor Group
Is it a sweet cookie? A savory snack? The ideal combo of both? Only you can decide! Try them iced with our Vanilla icing or plain.
BUTTERMILK MAPLE FLAPJACK SUGAR COOKIES
Premium Flavor Group
Who doesn’t love the taste of warm pancakes and syrup? So, what could be better than a portable hand-held version? Pairs perfect with Vanilla or Maple flavored icing.
STRAWBERRY CHEESECAKE SUGAR COOKIES
Premium Flavor Group
Freeze dried strawberries and real cream cheese lend the perfect flavor to these delicious cookies. Pair them with our Cream Cheese, Vanilla or Strawberry Icing for a delicious morsel in every bite.
BIRTHDAY BASH SUGAR COOKIES
Premium Flavor Group
This kicks the Birthday Sprinkle cookie and kicks it up a few notches with premium vanilla and other party flavors! This cookie can pair with a wide variety of flavors to suit your taste.
FRESH APPLE CIDER
Premium Flavor Group
This flavor has been one of our most well received flavors. Perfect for fall, or any time of year, really. Such a soft, delicious cookie, with or without icing!
PINK LEMONADE SUGAR COOKIES
Premium Flavor Group
A cool refreshing glass of Pink Lemonade - in a cookie! Pairs great with Vanilla Icing
BROWN BUTTER SALTED CARAMEL SUGAR COOKIES
Premium Price Group
Chewy, sweet, gooey and salty, all blended together in what just might be the perfect bite!
CRÈME BRÛLÉE SUGAR COOKIES
Premium Flavor Group
Brown butter and real cream pair for a decadent treat! Pairs well with our Vanilla icing.
SUPER S’MORES SUGAR COOKIES
Premium Flavor Group
A popular campfire treat now in a cookie! It’s got chocolate, graham crackers and even mini marshmallows!
CHEDDAR JALEPENO SUGAR COOKIE
Premium Flavor Group
Pair this delicious cookie with our Lime Royal Icing for a one-of-a-kind treat. This daring, bold cookie combo is just begging for you to try it! So what do you say? Do you dare??
PERFECTLY SWEET STRAWBERRY SUGAR COOKIES
Premium Flavor Group
These cookies smell divine both while they are baking and after. They are really almost irresistible - We have to remember to make extras with each batch so we have some “tasters.”
BUTTERSCOTCH TOFFEE BLISS SUGAR COOKIE
Premium Flavor Group
A little sweet, a little salty, a whole lotta yummy! The toffee bits in these cookies are absolutely delicious! Pairs well with Vanilla & Cream Cheese icing.
CHERRY CHOCOLATE CHIP SUGAR COOKIES
Premium Flavor Group
Chocolate covered cherries anyone? Pair this sweet treat with our Vanilla, Chocolate, Cream Cheese or Buttercream flavor icing.
MINT, MINT & MORE MINT (AND CHOCOLATE, TOO)
Premium Flavor Group
A decadent mix of peppermint, mint chocolate and mint sandwich cookies combine for one deep, dark, delicious bite of chocolate, minty goodness after another.
BLUEBERRY LEMON SUGAR COOKIE
Premium Flavor Group
Real freeze-dried blueberries and fresh lemon combine for the perfect balance of tart and sweet in this cookie that is as beautiful decorated as it is plain. (Although, I do like the sweetness the icing adds to the flavor!)
CINNAMON BUN
Special Flavor Group
Sweet, delicious cinnamon buns, without the sticky fingers! These are quickly becoming a favorite!